Quick answer: Evaluate a slab-only replacement when the existing frame is sound, correctly aligned and compatible with the new door. Consider a complete prehung unit when the frame or sill is deteriorated, or the entry needs more extensive correction. A damaged door panel does not automatically require a new frame—but a new panel will not repair a failing opening. Have an installer assess the entry before ordering. (images.thdstatic.com)
For U.S. homeowners. Prices below are in U.S. dollars; pricing evidence was checked November 22, 2026.
1. What a slab-only replacement and a prehung unit include
The slab is the moving door panel. Replacing it means retaining the existing frame and checking that the replacement works with the hinges, latch location and weather-sealing components already there. Therma-Tru’s troubleshooting guide identifies slab replacement as a possible response to a cracked or dented door. (thermatru.com)
A prehung exterior unit has the door mounted in a frame. The entry system also uses a sill, weatherstripping and other components selected for its configuration. Ask the supplier to list exactly what is included rather than assuming that “complete” includes locks, finished trim or painting. Therma-Tru’s system information distinguishes among these separate components and their applications. (s3.amazonaws.com)
Use this distinction when requesting estimates:
- Slab-only proposal: What remains, and how will compatibility be confirmed?
- Prehung proposal: What is removed, what is supplied, and how will the surrounding opening be finished?
- Either proposal: What problems does the installer expect this scope to solve?
Do not compare the two options by the door’s purchase price alone. Request a finished-project price for each viable approach.
2. Assess the frame and threshold before choosing
Start with the existing entry’s condition, not a preferred door style. Therma-Tru’s replacement checklist flags deteriorated frames, poor operation, air gaps, rotting subfloor and water entering the home as reasons to investigate replacement. These signs warrant assessment; they do not, individually, establish the required scope. (s3.amazonaws.com)
Ask the installer to evaluate:
- Whether the frame is sound and securely supported.
- Whether it is square, level and plumb.
- Whether the sill and supporting material are deteriorated.
- Whether staining or recurring wetness indicates an unresolved water problem.
- Whether the proposed slab can fit without prohibited alterations.
JELD-WEN’s exterior slab instructions require an acceptable existing jamb and say not to install the slab if the stated conditions are not met. Professional correction may be necessary first. (images.thdstatic.com)
A worn seal does not necessarily mean a failed frame. Therma-Tru’s troubleshooting guide treats weatherstrip, sill and alignment problems separately from damage to the slab. Ask whether compatible replacement parts or an adjustment should be evaluated before replacing the entire entry. (thermatru.com)
Conversely, request a prehung assessment when retaining the frame would leave deterioration or alignment problems unresolved. If the supporting opening is damaged, the proposal should address that separately—not merely specify a new door. (cmd-jeld-wen.s3.us-east-2.amazonaws.com)
3. Confirm measurements, handing and hardware preparation
A size label is not a complete order specification. Therma-Tru’s measuring material distinguishes the door, frame and rough opening; its dimensional tables also show that nominal door size, actual unit size and required opening size differ. Use the selected product’s current documentation for the final order. (s3.amazonaws.com)
Have the installer and supplier confirm these details in writing:
| Detail | What to confirm |
|---|---|
| Slab dimensions | Actual width, height and thickness—not just the nominal size |
| Frame fit | Available opening dimensions and required clearances |
| Hinges | Number, size, location and preparation |
| Handing and swing | Exact manufacturer designation, supported by a sketch |
| Lock preparation | Bore dimensions, backset and compatibility with the selected hardware |
| Prehung dimensions | Overall unit size, rough-opening requirements and frame depth |
These checks reflect the separate fit, handing and preparation requirements in the manufacturers’ documentation. (images.thdstatic.com)
Backset is the distance from the door edge to the center of the main lock bore. Schlage’s checklist includes 2⅜-inch and 2¾-inch backsets, but the instructions for the exact lock should control. Do not assume an existing lock will transfer simply because the replacement door looks similar. (schlage.com)
For handing, ask for a drawing showing the exterior, hinge side and swing direction. Approve that drawing alongside the supplier’s designation. This is clearer than placing an order that says only “left-hand.” Therma-Tru’s published handing diagrams explicitly identify the viewing direction. (thermatru.com)
4. Separate weather sealing from water management
Ask the installer to explain two different parts of the work:
Door-to-frame sealing: How will the weatherstrip and door-bottom components work with the selected slab and sill? Therma-Tru identifies different door-bottom and sill arrangements for inswing and outswing systems. A replacement slab therefore needs more than matching face dimensions. (s3.amazonaws.com)
Frame-to-building weatherproofing: How will the unit connect to the surrounding wall and drain water outward? JELD-WEN’s prehung instructions address sill-pan flashing, integration with the water-resistive barrier and an exterior drainage path. A prehung unit still requires that site work. (cmd-jeld-wen.s3.us-east-2.amazonaws.com)
Put this question in the quote request:
“Please describe the sealing and flashing work included, and identify anything that cannot be assessed until the existing unit is removed.”
Avoid requesting a blanket bead of caulk around every edge. JELD-WEN’s instructions preserve specific drainage paths; indiscriminate sealing is not a substitute for the applicable installation detail. Leave that detail to the installer following the selected system’s instructions. (cmd-jeld-wen.s3.us-east-2.amazonaws.com)
5. Choose material and finish without assuming interchangeability
Steel, fiberglass and wood can all enter the discussion, but material choice does not eliminate the compatibility checks.
- Steel: Check the finish-care requirements and exposure. Steel surfaces can scratch or dent, and damaged finishes can present corrosion concerns.
- Fiberglass: Smooth and wood-grain appearances are available, but finishing requirements depend on the product.
- Wood: Consider the appearance alongside the need to maintain its protective finish and manage weather exposure.
NAHB’s front-door guide describes these material trade-offs; they are not guarantees about every model. (nahb.org)
Ask for the slab material and frame material on the proposal. Then ask who is responsible for factory finishing, field finishing and installation touch-ups.
Do not assume a slab can be shortened to solve a mismatch. Therma-Tru’s FAQ, for example, says it does not recommend cutting door height on site. Obtain the exact model’s modification limits before ordering. (thermatru.com)
Likewise, avoid a generic instruction to “paint both faces.” Therma-Tru specifies finishing exposed sides, edges and ends for relevant products, while JELD-WEN’s cited slab guide calls for finishing all six sides. Have the installer identify the applicable finishing instructions and who will complete that work. (thermatru.com)
6. Compare complete costs, not an assumed slab-only discount
There is no verified universal saving for slab-only replacement. The useful comparison is between two written proposals that address the same finished appearance, hardware and performance concerns.
As checked November 22, 2026, Home Depot’s U.S. cost guide lists $368–$1,378 for basic single-entry-door installation. It describes its figures as national averages that vary by market, and its installation-cost guidance excludes the door itself. The page does not establish separate slab-only and prehung price ranges. Treat it as a limited installation benchmark—not an all-in budget or a local quote. (homedepot.com)
Request separate amounts or clear inclusions for:
- Door slab or prehung assembly.
- Installation and any required hardware preparation.
- Locks, hinges and compatible sealing components.
- Removal and disposal.
- Flashing and opening repairs, where applicable.
- Interior and exterior trim restoration.
- Painting, staining and touch-ups.
- Taxes and any applicable permit charges.
This is a comparison checklist, not a claim that every project needs every item. Ask each bidder to mark items included, excluded or subject to inspection.
For concealed damage, request a written process: photographs, a description of the problem, an additional price and approval before extra work proceeds. Keep that potential work distinct from the base replacement price.
7. Work through two different entry conditions
Example A: A straightforward front-door refresh
Suppose the goal is a different panel design, with no change to the opening or swing. Ask for a slab-only assessment first. The decision depends on verified frame condition and compatibility—not the cosmetic goal alone. A cracked or dented panel may be a slab-replacement candidate under Therma-Tru’s troubleshooting guidance. (thermatru.com)
Work through the proposal in this order:
- Obtain written confirmation that the retained frame is suitable.
- Have the supplier confirm the replacement slab and hardware preparation.
- Identify any seals, hinges or finishing work to be replaced or renewed.
- Compare that complete scope with a prehung alternative if both are feasible.
Example B: A deteriorated entry
Suppose the entry has recurring water intrusion and deterioration near the sill. Request an assessment of the opening and a prehung option rather than a slab-only purchase based on appearance. Those symptoms appear on Therma-Tru’s replacement checklist, while JELD-WEN requires structurally sound rough-opening framing for retrofit installation. (s3.amazonaws.com)
Ask the contractor to distinguish the replacement unit from investigation, water-management corrections and repairs. Do not accept an unexplained allowance as proof that the cause has been identified.
These are decision examples, not completed projects or quoted prices. The evidence does not support assigning either one a reliable all-in total.
8. Check the order and finished work before signing off
Before authorizing an order, ask:
- Who owns final measurement responsibility?
- Which frame and sealing components will remain?
- Is the swing documented with an approved drawing?
- Are hardware and finishing responsibilities explicit?
- What happens if concealed damage is discovered?
- Which installation instructions and warranty documents apply?
At completion, check operation with the installer. Schlage recommends checking whether an exterior door locks without lifting, pulling or pushing it. Ask the installer to demonstrate the latch and deadbolt, explain seal maintenance and show the completed finishing work. (schlage.com)
The practical rule: preserve a suitable frame when the verified replacement can work with it; expand the scope when retaining it would leave the underlying problem unresolved. Choose after assessment, not after comparing two door price tags. (images.thdstatic.com)